A dictator's apprencticeship
by Brigitte Hamann
Around 1150, when the dukes of Babenberg made Vienna
their residence, they brought Jews into the city, who settled in
the area of today's Judenplatz (Jew square), worked as money lenders
and tradespeople, and enjoyed the sovereigns' special protection-paying
considerable taxes in return. As early as 1200 Vienna had its first
Over the course of the centuries, there were intermittent
phases of expulsion, "Jewish auto-da-fes," and resettlements.
The situation became particularly dangerous at the time of the Turkish
Wars in the seventies century, when religious fanaticism was by
no means directed only at the Turks but at the native Jews as well.
In 1623 the 130 Jewish families in Vienna were banned from the inner
city and forcefully resettled in a new ghetto between the forks
of the Danube. At the instigation of his Spanish wife Margarita
Teresa, Emperor Leopold I had all Jews expelled in 1670. They lost
their property and all valuables, were only allowed to take with
them what they could carry , and had to consider themselves lucky
that they did not lose their lives. The Viennese set fire to the
synagogue and in its place erected a church dedicated to the Emperor's
saint. The ghetto turned into a new Catholic suburb, Leopoldstadt.
Only a few years later the emperor, now a widower and in need of
money, brought the Jews back to Vienna. They again settled in what
was now Leopoldstadt, which was soon scornfully nicknamed "Matzohville."
As late as 1900 approximately one third of all Viennese Jews lived
The Christian Socials compared the existential
battle between the Christian Occident and the heathen Turks to the
"defense battle" against the Jews. Thus during the mayoral
campaign of 1895 Lueger shouted: "Today is the memorable day
of Vienna's liberation from the Turks, and let's hope that we
can avert a danger from us that is greater than the Turkish threat
: the Jewish threat." According to a newspaper report, the
speech was followed by "thundering applause and endless shouts
Modem anti-Semitism hit the Jews in Austro-Hungary
in what was probably the happiest phase in their history .After
centuries of oppression, the liberal national basic law of 1867
had brought them equal rights, completely and without qualification.
Now they could finally enjoy all those large and small liberties
that had been denied them for centuries. They were allowed to own
property in the capital, could choose where they wanted to live,
become governmental civil servants, attend universities without
restrictions, and more.
An immediate consequence of emancipation was a
wave of Jewish immigrants into the capital and imperial residence.
Before the emancipation, in 1860, 6,200 Jews lived in Vienna, which
represented a 2.2 percent share of the population; in 1870, there
were 40,200 Jews, which was 6.6 percent; in 1880 the numbers were
72,600 and 10.1 percent, respectively. In 1890 Vienna had 118,500
Jews who, however, after the incorporation of the suburbs, only
represented 8.7 percent. This percentage remained a constant in
the rapidly growing city. In 1900, 147,000, and in 1910, 175,300
Jews lived in Vienna - religious Jews, to be sure. Following the
criterion of ethnic anti-Semitism, which had become popular by then
- that is to say, including assimilated and baptized Jews - the
numbers were much larger.
Most of these 175,300 religious Jews, 122,930,
were part of the German share of the population, including the Eastern
Jews, whose Yiddish was regarded as German. According to their everyday
language, the rest were Poles, Czechs, Romanians, and others. The
51,509 Jews in Vienna who were registered as "aliens"
were mostly Hungarians. These statistics do not reveal how large
the share of Russian Jews was, for most of the refugees had not
settled yet and were not included in any statistic.
Among the Dual Monarchy's cities, Vienna had by
no means the largest share of Jews. In Cracaw they represented 50
percent, in Lernberg and Budapest, 25 percent, and in Prague, 10
percent. Compared to other large cities in Europe, however, Vienna's
share was very high. The Jewish share in Berlin was between 4 and
5 percent, and in Hamburg 2 to 3 percent.
The euphoria triggered by the freedom the immigrants
had finally achieved, motivated many of them to great achievements.
All doors seemed to be open to those who worked hard. Emancipation
fanned their desire to become respected members of society by way
of achievement and education.
In the Catholic-conservative atmosphere of Vienna,
which was still largely characterized by bourgeois complacency and
had a hard time dealing with the innovations of the modem age, the
Jews who were education-conscious and eager for success encountered
little competition. The writer Jakob Wassermann, for example, who
had immigrated from Berlin, noted this with astonishment. The nobility
, he observed, which had formerly been the leading social class,
was "entirely indifferent": it "not only kept cautiously
away from intellectual and artistic life, but was also afraid of
it and despised it. The few patrician bourgeois families imitated
the nobility; an autochthonous bourgeoisie no longer existed, and
the gap was filled by civil servants, officers, and professors;
below them was the closed bloc of the petit bourgeoisie." In
short : "The court, the petit bourgeoisie, and the Jews gave
the city its character. That the Jews as the most mobile group kept
all the other groups constantly on the move, is no longer astonishing.
Jews' different driving power and value systems expressed
themselves mainly in their eagerness to get an education.
In 1912 one out of three high school students in Vienna
was a religious Jew - three times more than their share
of the population. [InAustria, attending high school
is not obligatory but one among several possible ways of
receiving a "higher education." Pupils can attend
elementary school up to the age of fourteen and then move
on to professional schools. (Translator's note) ]
All types of secondary schools put together, the share of
Jewish students was 47.4 percent in 1912 - almost half.
Although if theology is excluded only 5.3 percent
of altogether ten thousand Christians attended university between
1898 and 1902, the figure among Jews was 24.5 percent. Jewish students
made up almost one third of all university students in Vienna. Jewish
students' preferred majors were medicine - in 1913, they constituted
more than 40 percent of all students of medicine in Vienna - and
law: in 1913 more than one quarter of all law students were Jewish.
Jews preferred the independent professions of lawyer
Of altogether 681 lawyers in Vienna in 1889, more
than half -394- were Jewish. Twenty years before, there were only
In Cisleithania, most Jews adopted the dominant
nationality, at least culturally and economically: German. They
loved German language and culture, were enthusiastic about Richard
Wagner, whose most modern interpreter was Gustav Mahler, and felt
themselves to be German- Austrians. Between 1867 and 1914 Vienna
became a metropolis of modern art and science, especially in the
fruitful symbiosis of Viennese and Jewish elements.
There were spectacular success stories in trade
and economy, such as that of department store king Alfred Gerngross,
which after his death in 1908 was told everywhere. Having emigrated
from Frankfurt to Vienna with his brother in 1881, he opened up
a fabric store, then bought one house after the other on Vienna's
largest business street, Mariahilfer Strasse, and built a huge department
store. He left his eight children a fortune of more than four million
kronen. Those craftsmen whom Hitler knew personally as buyers of
his pictures were successful too : frame-maker Jakob Altenberg from
Galicia, glazier Samuel Morgenstern from Hungary.
"Jewish intelligence" became a standing
expression in Vienna around 1900. The writer Hermann Bahr joked
that every aristocrat "who is a little bit smart or has some
kind of talent, is immediately considered a Jew; they have no other
explanation for it."
Although Gustav Mahler had been baptized long before,
Alfred Roller believed he could detect in his friend a downright
"Jewish" compulsion to work hard : Mahler never hid his
Jewish background. But it didn't give him joy. It motivated and
urged him on to higher, purer achievements. "Like when someone
is born with one arm too short: then the other arm has to learn
to accomplish even more and eventually perhaps accomplishes things
that both healthy arms couldn't have achieved. That's how he once
explained to me the effect of his background on his work."
The growing social reputation of Jews who had become
rich found its expression in mansions on the Ring Boulevard, which
were as if in competition with the palaces of the old nobility,
in the medals and titles which the emperor bestowed on them in return
for their accomplishments and generous donations, and in spectacular
marriages of rich Jewish women with impoverished aristocrats.
The solution to the Jewish question, which was
thousands of years old, finally seemed to be in sight in the form
of total assimilation, including conversions and mixed marriages.
In this respect, however, there were obstacles to overcome. Mixed
marriages between religious Jews and religious Christians were prohibited.
In order to get married, one of the partners either had to convert
to the faith of the other or declare himself or herself unaffiliated
with any church. Either step was usually taken by the Jewish partner.
Between 1911 and 1914 such marriages occurred almost ten times as
frequently as marriages between Catholics and Protestants.
Politically the Jews tended to be in the liberal
or Social Democratic camp, as Representative Benno Straucher emphasized
in the Reichsrat in 1908: "We Jews were, are, and will remain
democratic, we can only flourish in democratic air, for us, reactionary
air is stuffy, we subscribe to a free, democratic weltanschauung,
therefore we can only pursue truly liberal policies."
This did not mean that they agreed on party politics.
The Zionist National-Zeitung complained in 1908 : "The
fourteen Jews in Parliament are members of five different parties."
Only the four Zionists and one "Jewish Democrat" were
openly Jewish, the others were Social Democrats or in the liberal
camp. Of the six Jewish deputies from Galicia, for example, three
were Zionists -that is to say, nationalist Jews- the other three
were Social Democrats.
The success of Jewish immigrants aroused jealousy
and hatred in those native residents who were left behind by the
sudden competition and could not deal with the modern era's innovations:
the craftsmen who lost their livelihood to the factories, the store
owners who were put at a disadvantage by the department stores.
Only six years after emancipation, during the crash of 1873, a new
wave of anti-Semitism was vented against the "capitalists,"
the "liberals," and the "stock exchange Jews."
In 1876 a storm started brewing at the universities,
which was triggered by the famous professor of medicine Theodor
Billroth's criticism of what he considered the disproportionately
large share of Jewish medical students from Hungary and Galicia.
Billroth questioned the success of assimilation, arguing "that
the Jews are a sharply defined nation, and that no Jew, just like
no Iranian, Frenchman, or New Zealander, or an African can ever
become a German; what they call Jewish-Germans are simply nothing
but Jews who happen to speak German and happened to receive their
education in Germany, even if they write literature and think in
the German language more beautifully and better than many a genuine
Germanic native. "Therefore [we should] neither expect nor
want the Jews ever to become true Germans in the sense that during
national battles they feel the way we Germans do."
Those Jews who had immigrated from the eastern
countries, he argued, were lacking "our German sentiments,"
which were based on "medieval Romanticism." Billroth admitted
that inside, "even though I have reflected about this a great
deal and do like some of them individually," he still felt
"the gap between purely German and purely Jewish blood to be
just as wide as the gap a Teuton may have felt between himself and
Now the German fraternities felt authorized to
expel their Jewish fellow students. The fraternity Teutonia introduced
the "Aryan Clause" as early as 1877" and the other
fraternities followed suit. The fraternities justified their actions
with an appeal to the Berlin philosopher Eugen Dühring and
his much-quoted remark: "The German students must regard it
as their honor that the sciences are presented to them-or rather,
bungled and contaminated in a Jewish way" and traded off-not
by an alien and much inferior race which is entirely incapable of